Wednesday, 23 January 2008
NORMAL SERVICE WILL RESUME SHORTLY
Sunday, 23 December 2007
GOVERNMENT'S DATA WOES: FIPR'S PROGNOSIS
- The multi-billion pound identity card scheme, to hold data on the whole population;
- The National Health spine, which will make everyone's health records available for browsing by a million NHS workers;
- ContactPoint which will record details on every child in England, with details of their parents, carers and indicators of whether they have any contact with social services. Three hundred thousand people can look that information up;
- A universal pensioner's bus pass scheme which will hold the data on 17 million people, and in principle will let any bus driver learn your age and address -- when all that it should record is an entitlement to free travel.
Ross Anderson, Chair of FIPR and Professor of Security Engineering at the University of Cambridge said, "the Government believes that you can build secure databases and let hundreds of thousands of people access them. This is nonsense -- we just don't know how to build such systems and perhaps we never will. The correct way to design such systems is to localise the data, in a school, in your local GP practice. That way when there is a compromise because of a technical failure or a dishonest user then the damage is limited.
"You can have security, or functionality, or scale -- you can even have any two of these. But you can't have all three, and the Government will eventually be forced to admit this. In the meantime, billions of pounds are being wasted on gigantic systems projects that usually don't work, and that place citizens' privacy and safety at risk when they do."
Richard Clayton, FIPR Treasurer said, "Personal data ought to be handled as if it were little pellets of plutonium -- kept in secure containers, handled as seldom as possible, and escorted whenever it has to travel. Should it get out into the environment it will be a danger for years to come. Putting it into one huge pile is really asking for trouble. The Government needs to completely rethink its approach and abandon its Transformational Government disaster.""
WHAT DID I TELL YOU?
Saturday, 22 December 2007
GOVERNMENT'S DATA SECURITY WOES
BEST WISHES OF THE SEASON
Tuesday, 18 December 2007
LIBDEMS' LEADERSHIP RACE
Monday, 17 December 2007
WOMEN'S PENSIONS
When they will report on their commitment, made during the passage of the Pensions Act 2007 through Parliament, to help women to buy back additional national insurance years.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Work and Pensions (Lord McKenzie of Luton): My Lords, the Government committed to look at a range of options to help individuals who have gaps in their national insurance contribution records to purchase additional voluntary contributions. This work is now complete. The options were analysed in terms of fairness, affordability and simplicity. The Government have concluded that none of the options considered passes these assessment criteria and none is particularly well targeted, and therefore have decided to make no changes to the current rules to allow individuals to buy additional national insurance contributions. (So, as per standard NuLabour practice, the commitment we made wasn't the one anybody else thought it was and, even if it was, we're not going to honour it anyway - so there!)
Baroness Hollis of Heigham: My Lords, I am profoundly dismayed by that Answer. In my view, it will not do. (And I'm mightily pissed off that the Government of which I was once a (reasonably) prominent member is behaving in such a shabby way.) Does my noble friend accept that there are coming before the Commons, and therefore to your Lordships’ House in due course, the National Insurance Contributions Bill and the personal accounts Pensions Bill and that, if this House agrees, we will continue to fight to ensure that women who have been carers do not find themselves penalised by going into retirement with an incomplete, poor pension? (And there will be blood on the Government carpet once we've cobbled together a cross-party alliance to defeat them on the issue.)
Lord McKenzie of Luton: My Lords, I well understand the disappointment of my noble friend and others in the House, particularly as she has campaigned so effectively on this issue, but the position is as I have outlined. We should not lose sight of what has happened under this Government in improvements to pensions, particularly for women. For example, the reduction in the number of qualifying years needed for a full basic state pension is 30—a key measure—and, for the first time, paid and credited contributions for caring will be recognised equally for basic state pension and state second pension. (We've done our bit and thrown money at just about everything under the sun; the only trouble is we're beginning to run out of the stuff so we can't afford to pay for this. And frankly we've made such a mess of the economy that it's all going belly up in the next few months.) Those are important developments, but I am well aware that this debate is quite likely to continue with those two pieces of legislation. (And I'm not looking forward to it.)
Lord Fowler: My Lords, does the Minister not remember that when the proposal of the noble Baroness, Lady Hollis, was put to this House it was agreed to by a margin of 179 votes to 86? Surely it is a sensible measure; it gives flexibility and it particularly helps women in retirement. Frankly, the sooner it is done, the better. (The Conservatives will stand four square behind any proposals Baroness Holls may bring forward.)
Lord McKenzie of Luton: My Lords, I am not sure that we on this side should take any lessons from the pensions record of the Conservatives. (I'm getting a bit tetchy so better use this default response; and if things continue to be a bit tricky, I'll have to resort to giving ourselves a glowing report on our record in Government too.) The challenge for the measures was to reach those people whom my noble friend most wanted to reach but not to have to bear the cost of the others. That has been the difficulty. For example, if this is a policy commitment that the Opposition want to take on, let me explain that the option of an extra nine years pre-2010 and six years post-2010 would cost in cash terms a bit short of £5 billion to 2050—net present value, in prices terms, £1.3 billion. (As I've said, we've made such a mess of the economy - and got all our spending priorities wrong - so we can't afford it.) That is the analysis and that is the issue before us.
Lord Davies of Coity: My Lords, is my noble friend aware that, when I became general-secretary of my trade union in 1986, I inherited a situation in which part-time women workers were ineligible for the pension scheme? I not only provided for them to become members of the scheme but I backdated the years of service to ensure that they paid money for those years that they had already completed. (Gizzajob!) I hope that the Government do the same with the national insurance contributions.
Lord McKenzie of Luton: My Lords, pensioners have been well served by this Government. Let us look at the facts of what has happened since 1997. (Phew, a soft ball that I can bat back by bleating about our record.) Currently, only around 35 per cent of women reaching state pension age are entitled to a full basic state pension. When the 2010 changes come in, that figure will be three-quarters and, in 2025, 90 per cent, which will be equality with men. Because of the changes that we have made to the state second pension, 2.1 million carers, more than 90 per cent of them women, and 6.1 million low earners, almost 60 per cent of them women, are included in the scheme, which did not provide for them before.
Lord Oakeshott of Seagrove Bay: My Lords, does the Minister accept that, today of all days, when the Government have finally run up the white flag after their appalling treatment of the 125,000 robbed pensioners, this is the last day to try to defend the indefensible on this issue? I give notice that, along with the noble Baroness, Lady Hollis, we on these Benches will be fighting as hard as we can during consideration of the upcoming Pensions Bill to ensure that people get justice. (Can we join in - in a squeaky voice - and clobber the Government too with our tickling sticks?) Does the Minister not accept that what is happening here is a Labour Government spending billions to help rich people by giving them top-rate tax relief and preventing poor women, with broken work records, from saving for a modest pension?
Lord McKenzie of Luton: My Lords, it must be easy being a Liberal Democrat: you are responsible for nothing and it does not matter what spending commitments you make, as we see far too often. (I'm definitely getting very tetchy now especially as those fluffy LibDems are having a go at me too. Leave me alone. I didn't make the mess we're in and, anyway, this lark of 'defending the indefensible' is above my pay grade. Just leave me alone.) If one looks at who would not benefit from the proposals, one sees that it would be the poorest women, because the poorest women headed for pension credit would lose pound for pound if they were asked to cough up for additional class 3 contributions. The proposals would not help those women who could not get beyond 60 per cent of their spouse’s pension; they would simply be paying in money to no avail. It is not right to characterise it as the noble Lord has done.
Baroness Greengross: My Lords—
Baroness O'Cathain: My Lords—
Baroness Dean of Thornton-le-Fylde: My Lords—
Noble Lords: The Cross Benches. (See ... self-regulation works!?!)
Baroness Greengross: My Lords, the Government are developing a strategy for carers across the board and I am pleased to be part of that work, but surely it is beyond belief that a group of carers and people who have had caring responsibilities are going to be discriminated against in recouping the pensions that they could have been entitled to if they not taken on that role. (I'm signing up to supporting Baroness Hollis.) Will the Government please reconsider, because this is extremely unfortunate?
Lord McKenzie of Luton: My Lords, I stress again that the challenge has been to reach the very people whom the noble Baroness describes. (They won't notice notice if I repeat the same old garbage; even if they do, time is nearly up so, if I can pad it out just a little bit more ....) That is not possible without great intricacies and complications, which is one of the criteria that we set our face against when we discuss these things in this House. The reality is that the role of carers going forward is significantly improved for the reasons that we gave when we debated the Pensions Bill earlier this year. (Thank God that's over!)
Sunday, 16 December 2007
WILL GOVERNMENT LISTEN?
MAJOR'S INTERVENTION
- "The Conservatives' broken promises taint all politics. That is why we have made it our guiding rule not to promise what we cannot deliver; and to deliver what we promise. What follows is not the politics of a 100 days that dazzles for a time, then fizzles out. It is not the politics of a revolution, but of a fresh start ...";
- "We are a broad-based movement for progress and justice. New Labour is the political arm of none other than the British people as a whole.";
- "Our mission in politics is to rebuild this bond of trust between government and the people. That is the only way democracy can flourish.";
- "We will clean up politics, decentralise political power throughout the United Kingdom and put the funding of political parties on a proper and accountable basis.";
- "There is unquestionably a national crisis of confidence in our political system, to which Labour will respond in a measured and sensible way.";
- "This is the purpose of the bond of trust I set out at the end of this introduction, in which ten specific commitments are put before you. Hold us to them. They are our covenant with you."
Saturday, 15 December 2007
FREEDOM OF SPEECH
Friday, 14 December 2007
GUILTY UNTIL PROVED INNOCENT
DUTCH MEDICAL DATABASE LEAKY AS A SIEVE
Thursday, 13 December 2007
ANOTHER STATEMENT OF THE BLEEDING OBVIOUS
TEBBIT HUMOUR/"SMART METERS"
Noble Lords: Oh!
Lord Rooker: My Lords, no, I am not going to answer that."
UNDERSTATEMENT OF THE YEAR? (CENTURY EVEN?)
PRIVACY IMPACT ASSESSMENTS
Wednesday, 12 December 2007
DATA-SHARING CONSULTATION/REVIEW
PLOD AT THE DOOR OF No.10 ... AGAIN?
Monday, 10 December 2007
PNR (PASSENGER NAME RECORD) DATA/THE PRUM TREATY
"the worst possible conclusion would be an agreement that again was accompanied by a letter allowing the United States to disregard its provisions almost at will. Yet this is precisely what emerged in July from the negotiations."
" ... with no consultation, no explanatory memorandum, no impact assessment, no overall evaluation of the operation of the treaty, no estimate of the cost to member states and minimal involvement of the European Parliament and national parliaments."
"Governments, Ministers and national officials are giving themselves arrogant licence to do what they like and then try to pull the wool over our eyes."
- "expenditures continue on projects that 'are not well-defined, planned, or justified on the basis of costs, benefits, and risks';
- "'management controls to identify and evaluate computer and operational problems were insufficient and inconsistently administered';
- "'contracts have not been effectively managed and overseen';
- "security 'weaknesses collectively increase the risk that unauthorized individuals could read, copy, delete, add, and modify sensitive information, including personally identifiable information'; and
- According to the chairman of the U.S. Senate Homeland Security Committee, Senator Joseph Lieberman, the U.S. government 'is spending $1.7 billion of taxpayer money on a program to detect potential terrorists crossing our borders yet it isn't taking the most basic precautions to keep them from hacking into and changing or deleting sensitive information.'"
Nor in fact is the output of PNR data programmes especially useful. As John Lettice points out - and I've no reason to doubt the figures - "out of 63 million visitors [subject to the US-VISIT programme] the DHS detected a whole 1,200 criminals and immigration violators. It is also thought that one person was detained in connection with terrorism, but it's not known what crime, if any, might have been involved, and what happened." In other words, so far as the primary purpose of the policy (i.e. countering terrorism) is concerned there is a 1 in 63 million chance that the system will throw up what might just, conceivably, be a positive and/or useful result. (As an aside, there is a read-across here to the UK Government's plans for ID cards as the total registrable population will be round about this sort of number. And, as I've blogged previously in the context of the IPS database, this raises the spectre of any PNR database - mark you, it would be pan-European rather than just being confined to the UK- being used as a substitute for the National Identity Register should ID cards be scrapped.) Now, I ask you, dear reader, whether you can discern any sort of proportionality in this sort of outcome?
All in all this sorry mess confirms for me beyond peradventure that I am right to be profoundly distrustful of letting the Government manage or administer my personal information in any way whatsoever. And I can't help feeling that it serves as a stark metaphor for so much that is wrong with the political process in our modern age. If governments are going to be so contemptuous and disdainful of its citizens and their legitimate rights as this sordid saga suggests, is it any wonder that they feel provoked to return the favour? Against the background of this sort of behaviour, purportedly acting in our 'democratic' interest, I say enough is enough and a plague on all your houses!!!
Footnote: A few days prior to the debate, the Admiral, in a written answer, referred to "travel document information" and "other passenger information" (with the acronyms "TDI" and "OPI" respectively) in the context of the UK's e-borders scheme. Now I've no idea whether these are an enitirely ne invention, equivalent to PNR data, or whatever. But it does seem like a classic way of muddying the waters by giving and old (but discredited) 'friend' a new nickname!