Monday, 10 December 2007

YAWN - LIB/DEM LEADERSHIP RACE - YAWN

So Vince (Vincent Price) Cable tells us the outcome of the Huhne/Clegg love-in - like me, aren't you just gagging to know the result? (I jest!!!) - is "very close".

Translation: "It's all been such a frightful, tedious palaver. Can't we just call it an unedifying 'bore draw' so that we can all get a life and leave the politics to those big boys in the Labour and Conservative parties?"

Friday, 7 December 2007

THE CROSBY REPORT

Those estimable fellows over at Ideal Government have recently posted this little gem.

Now, call me a hopeless cynic but I reckon the answer from Andy Burnham means that:
  1. The Report has in fact been read by Ministers - and the Great Bottler himself in particular - and so, to all intents and purposes is ready for public consumption. But they are resisting publication because ...

  2. It is a savage indictment of the architecture that the Government are currently proposing for their ID card scheme.

i.e. William Heath's take on it is absolutely spot on.

But, as I posted earlier, I am less certain that his 'seasoned Whitehall-watcher' has necessarily got it right in supposing that the Report is destined for some hinterland of long grass deep in the bowels of the Treasury. Rather I think that the Great Bottler reckons the Report may yet prove to be a potential ace up his sleeve.

Whatever else he may be he is a mightily shrewd politician - after all he commissioned the Crosby Forum in the first place when still Chancellor and you don't go to that trouble unless you're 90% confident that it will say what you want. Even then he will have actively considered the electoral downside of running with the ID cards project. His plan therefore was to make sure he had a get-out in place just in case the whole ID cards palaver went belly-up. Of course he can't have reckoned that, on the margins of the HMRC fiasco, it would do so quite so spectacularly. So at the moment his hands are tied because - call it control-freakery, hubris, pride, whatever you will - he can't take the risk of being controlled by events.

Nevertheless, timing is all. So, down the line when his political weather is a little bit sunnier and (always assuming if) he has regained some measure of control, he may well pull the proverbial rabbit of the Crosby Report out of the hat to justify scrapping ID cards, particularly if the prevailing winds tell him that to do so would be politically/electorally advantageous.

We shall see but, if nothing else, it's good to see David Davis sniffing around the issue - at least someone in Parliament is!

"DANCING ON THE EDGE OF DOOM"

The BBC reports on the Millennium Dome's insolvency here. This doesn't really tell us anything we didn't already suspect - or know. But the comment of Mike O'Connor, the head of the Millennium Commission at the time - "We always felt like we were dancing on the edge of doom" - seems weirdly appropriate to the parlous times that the Government currently finds itself in.

With the Great Bottler presiding over disaster after disaster (N.Rock, datagate, donorgate, &c) - most, if not all, of their own making - and white elephant after white elephant (ID cards, the NHS super-computer, ContactPoint, &c) leeching funds from the public purse, Ministers (and the Great Bottler himself) could perhaps be forgiven for approaching their cornflakes every morning with a certain unease. As I say, they must feel, in their heart of hearts, some semblance of this sentiment, that politically/electorally/financially/&c their administration really is "dancing on the edge of doom".


Update: Are you thinking what I'm thinking? Guido seems to be with his post today, "Government of All the Clowns". He quotes left-winger, John McDonnell MP:
  • “I think we’re in a mess. I think people are demoralised. I think Labour party members can’t understand how we’ve got in this mess. I think Gordon has shown, to be frank with you, ineptitude on a number of issues and so have some of the people around him.."

If that's not a "dancing on the edge of doom" sentiment, I'm not sure what is!



Thursday, 6 December 2007

DATA SECURITY: GOVT'S TRACK RECORD

Further to my previous post, I've been doing a little research. It would seem that (some of) the various legislative changes to the data protection/security regime that Richard Thomas is currently calling for have in fact already been before Parliament.

Back in March of this year in the House of Lords various amendments were debated in the context of the Serious Crime Bill aiming to strengthen the hand of the ICO vis a vis data protection/security. In fact, on 30th April and again on 9th May Baroness Anelay (now Opposition Chief Whip in the Lords but Home Office spokesman at the time) moved specific amendments (relevant debates available here and here) to ensure that the information commissioner would have the right to carry out assessments of data processing on his own volition. And, on 18th and 25th June respectively, Baroness Noakes (Opposition Treasury spokesman) and Earl Northesk initiated debates (here and here) on a similar provision on the face of the Statistics and Registration Service Bill.

In both cases, the Government rejected the amendments pretty much out-of-hand, although (it being the House of Lords) with some small measure of elegance. No surprise there then! Now, I'm not saying that, had they been accepted, the HMRC fiasco wouldn't have happened - though it might have made it less likely. Rather it is illustrative of the culture of complacency and indifference with which government thinking about and policy development of the needs of data security and protection is infected.

In passing I can't resist a barbed dig at the Lib Dems about this. Rationally this whole issue should be their natural territory but, in parliamentary and legislative terms, they give the impression of being completely unsighted about it. Instead - and happily - the Conservatives are making all the running on it with the 'yellow perils' being merely followers. It does beg the question as to what the Lib Dems are actually for if they can't be bothered to prosecute those matters that should be dearest to their hearts and underlying political philosophy. So, reckoning that the Conservatives in the House of Lords have a bee in their collective bonnets about this, is there a realistic prospect that they might introduce a PMB in the near future?

ONGOING DATAGATE FALL-OUT

As The Register' John Oates reports, Richard Thomas was giving evidence to the Justice Committee in the Commons yesterday. He specifically calls attention to this comment from the ICO's head honcho: "... several [Government] departments have come to see us on a confessional basis, ..."

Chilling stuff and - as if we didn't already know - indicative of wholesale systemic failure of data security arrangements and protocols not just at HMRC but across the whole panoply of Government. And which departments (I reckon the DWP is a likely candidate) have been donning their hair-shirts and pleading mea culpa? Perhaps more importantly, shouldn't these departments be making these confessions to us directly - more than likely it's our data at risk - rather than skulking off to the ICO with their tails between their legs perhaps in the hope that their laxity and incompetence will get conveniently swept under a carpet?

A further article from The Register (John Oates again) reports that Richard Thomas also insisted that his "his budget was insufficient and his powers too weak". In fact I was appalled to read that, whereas the ICO gets a total of £10m annually (essentially from registration fees), the Health & Safety Executive gets £890m - bet that makes Dizzy Thinks utterly apoplectic, given his loathing of the HSE - and the Food Standards Agency £143m. I reckon this arrangement says a huge amount about where Government places data security as a priority within the scheme of things. Additionally Richard Thomas sums up government IT policy pretty well if clouded a bit with the art of understatement: "There is excessive faith in technology perhaps without addressing the risks that go with collecting that information." And just for good measure he was decidedly lukewarm about ID cards as well. All in all, it looks as if he's gearing up a little to exert the indpendence of his office somewhat more forcefully than he perhaps has done so in the last five years.

In that vein and on a (slightly) happier note, he also recommends some eminently sensible things that the Government could be getting on with in the wake of 'datagate', specifically the creation of a new criminal offence and a statutory right of inspection of any given organisation's data security practices. Quite rightly he defines the current position in law, where he can only act with the consent or at the invitation of the relevant organisation, as "bizarre". So, will the Government bring forward appropriate legislation as a matter of urgency? Well, I'm not holding my breath! Or will the Opposition Parties get their collective acts together and try and run something as a Private Members' Bill? At the very least that would put pressure on the Government. Well, as usual we'll just have to wait and see.

Monday, 3 December 2007

PASSPORT/ID CARD SAGA

I thought I'd share with you a (perhaps not so) small tale of trouble and strife that has come to my attention.

I have an expatriate septugenarian friend, living in the US, who, because she is efficiency-minded, decided to attempt to renew her passport over this past summer - not urgently as it still has a year or so to run. Before the introduction of all this biometric malarkey, she would have applied by post to (I think) the consulate in Atlanta and the whole matter would have been turned round quickly and conveniently. Now, as the IPS web-page says: "Please note that we do not accept applications by post or e-mail if you live abroad." Manifestly those routes are closed to her. So she elected to try and get in touch with somone to ask how best to proceed. Six or so fruitless weeks later, having telephoned a bunch of automated call centres trying to get hold of a human being to talk to, she finally and frustratedly, chose to call the FCO in Whitehall directly only to get on the end of the line with some clueless girl whose only response to all of her questions was: "Ooooh ... um ... I dunno." She did finally extract a phone number from this dimwit of a girl, purportedly of the relevant section of the Embassy in Washington but when she rang it - yes, you've guessed it! - it was just another automated call centre. The upshot is that, despite being a UK citizen and a current UK passport holder, the only way she can renew is to go to the expense and inconvenience (considerable if one bears in mind all the additional accomodation costs, &c) of flying to either Washington or UK. And she is minded, almost in a fit of pique, not to bother.

A few points arise from this wretched saga. First, to state the bleeding obvious, it is ludicrous - even offensive - that a wholly legitimate citizen of the UK (with an equally legitimate expectation of all the rights that such a status confers) should be subjected to such inconvenience in this way. And no doubt there are a bunch of other people in a similar predicament. Such shabby and cavalier treatment would shame a banana republic.

Then one has to bear in mind that, for the purposes of the Identity Cards Act, a passport is a "designated" document (the 'compulsion by stealth' argument), the intention being that the data garnered for the purpose of issuing it will subsequently be used to seed the National Identity Register. One assumes therefore that the underlying motivation for all the palaver it is proposed my friend subjects herself to is to facilitate the collection of her relevant biometric identifiers and for a face-to-face interview to be conducted as a means of confirming various elements of her biographical details, all of which will be transferred (eventually) to the NIR. Now, if the ID cards project is scrapped - for whatever reason and/or whether by the Great Bottler or an incoming Conservative administration - the chilling fact is that all this data will continue to exist, albeit within the IPS database. In other words, the mere fact of scrapping ID cards doesn't in fact kill off the project for the vast majority of us (i.e. the 80% or so of the UK population who feel the need of a passport). It is conceivable that the electronic footprints of ourselves allowed for by the NIR would be less extensive under an IPS system but they would be there nonetheless. And then we have to add PNR data into the mix. There may not yet be specific statutory provision for 'linking' this to the IPS database, but we have to reckon that our lords and masters have doing so firmly in their minds. And such augmentation/consolidation of data would deliver biographical templates of us that would be pretty much equivalent to (perhaps even better on the basis of the information that could be inferred by any half-way decent AI-programme) those envisaged by the NIR.

There is too the specific provision on the face of the Identity Cards Act that only those resident in the UK for longer than three months need consider registering. The point here is that anyone applying for a passport out-of-country, although they have no statutory obligation whatsoever to buy into the NIR or ID cards all the time that they remain abroad, are in fact compelled so to do if they want to have a passport. In effect, the arrangements are such that the Government is circumventing the strict letter of the law.

As I say, I just thought I'd share this with you. And I'd welcome any thoughts anyone may have as to how my friend might be able to resolve her problem.

Sunday, 2 December 2007

POTS & KETTLES

Despite my best efforts, I can't rid my mind of 'donorgate'!!!

So, here's a thought - perhaps sometimes we can be too insular. Can you imagine the next time that Mugabe or the Burmese regime or anyone of that ilk offends against our sense of decency or commits some sort of atrocity? The young whippersnapper, Milliband, will call the relevant cronies into the FCO and say: "Well, look here chaps. We can't have this going on, ya know. It's just not cricket... you know, it's so corrupt." Said cronies begin giggling behind their hands. The short-trousered one, by now looking a bit pasty and red-faced, might feel inclined to add: "And...errrm...we just don't do that sort of thing over here, don't you know." And said cronies start rolling about on the floor!

QED really.

DONORGATE

With all the brouhaha about the above - and with so many others far more eloquent and effective than me on the case - I've little enough to add. (In fact, I'm so cheesed off and appalled by the whole sordid mess that I think I'm going to try and do something a little more useful than letting my blood boil about it for the rest of the week-end!!!)

But, like others (not least this from Burning Our Money), it is worth emphasising the point as vehemently as possible that there is categorically no justification for the Great Bottler using his party's mendacity/incompetence (see Matthew Parris' article here for 'guidance') as an 'excuse' to wish upon us (the innocent and long-suffering public) state funding of political parties. It is unlike him but Guido puts it rather more gently: "There is no real need for new laws or reviews, there is a need for politicians to simply not break the existing laws." And this, of course, is the real point - if this miserable shower can't comply with the laws that they themselves have introduced, then they should face the full consequences of having broken that law.

Friday, 30 November 2007

HUBRIS ABOUNDS

James Cleverly asks the question : "Is Labour rotten to the core?" Well, given recent events, the simple answer would have to be a resounding "Yes!"

But there is an intense irony in the current situation. In a quite palpable sense, the Great Bottler is inheriting what Bliar had sown during his period in office; in other words, Bliar's immediate 'legacy' to the clunking fist is to mire him ever deeper in the sleaze that so dogged his last days. According to the BBC, that (Man-of-) Straw, Jack, accepts the underlying principle in this and believes that "there [are] questions to be asked of Tony Blair, because many of the donations were made when he was Prime Minister". So much for all that tosh about leaving front-line UK politics with the public begging for more!

Isn't it strange too - almost 'ass-covering' one might say - that Bliar has been seeking to distance himself from his pre- (and post-) 1997 savaging of Major and the Tories over sleaze? His football analogy is especially apposite - it suggests that he knows full well that he 'took a dive' in order to gain political advantage. Regret on his part? Well, he says yes. Contrition? No way. But, more intriguingly, this sort of intervention from the sidelines must be making the Great Bottler apoplectic. Having effectively dumped him in it, the only Christmas present his old boss can offer him is that it was all a load of stuff-and-nonsense anyway. As for Blair, I have the teeniest suspicion that he might be just be revelling in the Great Bottler's discomfort - a sort of arrogant "Well, Gordo, it's not as easy as you thought" and "Now you know why I kept you out of No. 10 for so long" attitude.

Mind you, the Great Bottler may have already sown some seeds of revenge. Taken together with Straw's comment above, his insistence that the mess of the Abrahams donations is "illegal" is tacit acknowledgment that our erstwhile PM may well have a criminal charge to answer to. Could it be that he will have his collar felt again by the men in blue as they act on the Electoral Commission's referral of the file to them?

As to the hubris in all of this - and the thing that is so odious to anyone observing from the outside - it is the mind-numbing way in which all the players can just sit there and maintain that they personally have done nothing wrong - Hain is an absolutely classic example ("administrative error" doesn't cut it!). It beggars belief that they really imagine that we will be prepared to take such mendacious posturing seriously.

FACEBOOK CHOOSES DATA PRIVACY

This is extremely good news - and, despite being forced so to do, Facebook have made the right decision. I cannot help feeling that it should be a fundamental principle of data privacy that "opt-in" rather than "opt-out" systems should be the default - except in very exceptional circumstances. Now if only our 'lords and masters' could get their heads round this little bit of techno common-sense, wouldn't the world be a better place?

One other thought. It is often assumed/maintained that the IT generation has little interest in precepts of personal privacy/confidentiality (as per this sort of stuff). I have never accepted that view and have tended to feel that, in the rush to be techno-savvy and have all the latest gizmos to play with, people have ignored such considerations and laid them to one side. But, as they have become more aware of the potential implications/repercussions of their online activity, so such concerns have surfaced with more solidity in their minds - no doubt the HMRC fiasco has fine-tuned them in spades! The campaign that led to Facebook's having to climb down over this would seem to confirm this view.

(MORE) EDUCASHUN, EDUCASHUN, EDUCASHUN

Hot on the heels of my post yesterday about our kids slipping down the literacy league table, we are now told that they're getting worse at science too. I especially like Joe Fay's line: "... the nation's youth probably won't be too upset about their unboffinish performance – it's not like they'd be able to read about it after all." Mind you, given the US ranking, perhaps we don't have quite so much to worry about.

Thursday, 29 November 2007

EXCUSES, EXCUSES

Two stories from The Register have caught my eye, this and this.

So, on the one hand, we've got to stop our kids from pigging out on their video games fest so that they can get out there and play footie. On the other, according to Goggle-Eyed Balls, we've got to do it so that they can bury their heads in more books. Umm!?!

Usual stuff, really - dimwits trying to establish a direct causal relationship where none exists (and, in respect of the latter, just so much spin). The sad reality is that our blokes aren't very good at footie because they aren't managed very well - lest you doubt it consider the 'reasons' that Terry Venables or Alex Ferguson attribute to their respective teams' failings in the article (they're new slants on that perennial favourite of "Why the trains don't run on time"). Quite apart from that, nine times out of ten, the other lot are much better than us!

And the reason our kids are getting worse at reading is that the Government's/Bliar's much-trumpeted attempts to concentrate on "educashun, educashun, educashun" have had the perverse effect of making matters infinitely worse - to wit slipping from 3rd to 15th in the league table of reading skills.

BACK IN THE SPIN CYCLE?

Now here's a thought.

In these parlous times for New Labour, is it worth wondering how different things could have been? In the bad old days of Bliar, the man himself would have chosen (essentially) to sit back and ride out the storm - spinning the "well ... umm ... I'm a pretty straight sorta guy" line for as much as he was worth. And, to be fair, this tactic proved uncannily reliable in making sure that not too much (if any at all) effluent or excrement stuck to him. Like it or not, he was superb at that particular part of the politicians' stock-in-trade.

But he - or his underlings - would also have seen an opportunity in the current frenzy (and, on occasions, undoubtedly took advantage of it), namely to 'bury' any bad news stories that might be lurking in the Westminster/Whitehall undergrowth.

Now, the Great Bottler wouldn't try that on, would he? After all, he maintains the Bliar approach has been binned now that he's in the hot seat. We..ell ... the week-end approaches when the Westminster tribe seems to assume some sort of collective narcolepsy and this whole scrutiny thingie goes down the pan. I can't speak for anyone else but I'm going to make sure I'm keeping a pretty close eye on Departmental press releases for the next few days (perhaps even weeks or months if, as looks likely, the donation scandal continues to foment amongst the media).

ContactPoint "DELAYED"

So reports Kablenet. And a good thing too. Yippee!!!

But it is only a delay. And, needless to say, Goggle-Eyed Balls and his crew are trying to spin that the HMRC debacle is only a very minor consideration in this decision - as pointed out by John Oates here.

A few thoughts come to mind. The Written Statement insists that "ContactPoint will be a simple basic online tool" and seek to allay any anxiety by insisting that "No case information will be held on ContactPoint". As ever these dimwits singularly fail to understand that it is possible to infer a huge amount about any given individual from even the slimmest/most basic biographical data. For example, on their own admission, it will include "an indication as to whether a service or practitioner holds an assessment under the Common Assessment Framework or whether they are a lead professional for that child". Now, it doesn't take a genius to work out that, if an assessing "service", "practitioner" or "lead professional" is identified on the database, it becomes comparatively easy to work out the specific area of concern for/of that child. In other words, his/her data privacy and confidentiality has been circumvented.


In addition I've always struggled to understand how it is that a potential total user-base of 330,000 individuals - no doubt of the same calibre as those at HMRC - generates consistency with or confidence in the reassurance that "only cleared staff subject to the highest level of Criminal Records Bureau checks would be able to access the system". And, bearing in mind how adept Government staff have been at losing their laptops (see here), let us hope that those 330,000 people - I'm sure they're all good souls with no malicious intent!?! - can at least avoid dropping their random number generating tokens down the back of the train seat or what have you!

Wednesday, 28 November 2007

POLITICAL DONATION WOES

As others have said far more eloquently than I (there are any number of posts out there but Guido's coverage - available here - together with this and this from Iain Dale cover all the (current) bases), the scandal - and it is a scandal of mega-proportions - that has erupted over David Abrahams is beyond parody. File under the "You really couldn't make it up" department!!! And, as they are all saying, we've got to reckon we're only seeing the tip of the iceberg at the moment - as the media/blog pack sniffs and digs at the story, a whole bunch of nasties are going to be unearthed in due course.

But I can't help feeling that the real problem for us poor beleaguered citizens in all of this (Northern Rock, disk-gate, and now the donation scandal) is that increasingly the Great Bottler and his Government are in a state of (near) complete paralysis. One of the primary purposes of any administration is to get on and govern. But this shower are now so mired in sleaze, so much at the mercy of the blizzards of 'events' that are buffeting them, that that purpose seems to be flying out of the window minute by minute. It is perhaps too early to tell whether GB's administration is holed below the water-line - although Matthew Parris has his own take on that here. (Incidentally, one has to admire the prescience of Matthew's concluding paragraph: "Something is going to happen, something quite nasty. What, we must wait to see.") But it is legitimate to ask what on earth his bunch of malodorous incompetents are for if they are incapable of governing. Needless to say, this is the (unstated but inferred) narrative that underpinned David Cameron's savaging of the Great Bottler at PMQs.

Monday, 26 November 2007

ContactPoint DATA SECURITY

Kablenet, here, and The Register, here, both update us about the above. So ... whoop-de-do. We - and our kids - can now all sleep easy in our beds knowing that the DCFS is going to be looking after the sensitive personal data of our children securely and safely.

But, hey, hang on a minute! Call me cynical but isn't the substance of this - "strict access control", "two stage authentication process", &c - exactly what was meant to be in place over at HMRC? And it didn't help much there did it? Not uncommon with this shower, but in truth this is little more than another manifestation of The Government's technological illiteracy and the "Gotta-be-seen-to-be-doing-something" syndrome that rears its ugly head so often.

Friday, 23 November 2007

TRUSTING DATA SECURITY

On the face of it this from ECOTEC Research & Consulting (via cc:eGov, seemingly an offshoot of the European Commission's DG Information Society and Media's eGovernment Unit) makes a helluva lot of sense - although I haven't had a chance to read the whole report yet. I have to say too that I'm a little nonplussed that something as commonsensical as this has emanated from the EU. The BBC's report on this is here.

As their press release says, in the wake of the HMRC fiasco, their paper is "a timely reminder about the need to manage trust and security effectively." A masterpiece of understatement! And, as the Chairman of ECOTEC, John Bell, says: “This study has demonstrated that trust in public authorities and their technological systems is a key issue for governments across Europe and one that will not go away. Dealing with it will be the next great challenge for governments in the digital world”. Well ... actually it's been "a key issue" for the past decade or longer, and dealing with it is becoming more urgent with each passing day.

Given the history of all this, we'll have to wait and see whether there is a cat in hell's chance of any of it feeding into the development of policy whether at a pan-European level or by individual member states. But I'm not holding my breath that The Great Bottler and his cohort will have the wit to pick up this particular ball and run with it.

BLUNKETT: GENERAL IGNORANCE

Dizzy has an excellent hatchet job on David Blunkett's letter today to The Times. As he says the former Home Secretary - and, lest we forget in light of the HMRC debacle, former Secretary of State at the Department of Work and Pensions (how much of the 'systemic' failure within the Child Benefit system stems from his tenure of that office?) - "should shut up".

I've little enough to add - Dizzy covers all the bases superbly. But I have to admit that a wicked, perhaps even provocative in this politically correct age, thought came unbidden to my mind: "There's none so blind as them that can't see!"

P.S. Rest assured and for avoidance of doubt it's a commentary on his intellectual capacity rather than anything else.

Thursday, 22 November 2007

COULD 25m PEOPLE SUE HMRC?

On reading Iain Dale's post about this, I couldn't resist looking up the relevant text of the Data Protection Act. Section 13 seems to be the most pertinent provision. It states:

"13 Compensation for failure to comply with certain requirements

  1. An individual who suffers damage by reason of any contravention by a data controller of any of the requirements of this Act is entitled to compensation from the data controller for that damage.
  2. An individual who suffers distress by reason of any contravention by a data controller of any of the requirements of this Act is entitled to compensation from the data controller for that distress if—
    (a) the individual also suffers damage by reason of the contravention, or
    (b) the contravention relates to the processing of personal data for the special purposes.
  3. In proceedings brought against a person by virtue of this section it is a defence to prove that he had taken such care as in all the circumstances was reasonably required to comply with the requirement concerned."

I'm no lawyer but, on the face of it, anyone affected by the HMRC fiasco could sue for not only "damage" (i.e. financial loss, identity theft, or what-have-you) but also "distress" (i.e. mental anguish caused by the whole sorry episode, &c). Interesting.

But what really tickled me about this was the prospect of the Government, as a defence, seeking "to prove that [it] had taken such care as in all the circumstances was reasonably required" should anyone choose to take action against them. That really would be interesting!

TEACHERS' PERSONAL DATA

Dizzy has posted this about the 'privacy policy' of the Teaching and Development Agency For Schools.

As an addendum to his comments, it is worth having a look at Section 16 of the Data Protection Act. Presumably, under the terms of the Act, the TDA is compelled to notify the Information Commissioner's Office that it is a 'data controller'. As such it also has to provide the ICO - and, by extension, its data subjects via the expedient of its privacy policy - with a number of 'registrable particulars' which include (at sub-paragraph (1) (f)): "the names, or a description of, any countries or territories outside the European Economic Area to which the data controller directly or indirectly transfers, or intends or may wish directly or indirectly to transfer, the data,". The logic behind this, correctly identified by the text of the privacy policy statement is that "The data protection and other laws of these countries may not be as comprehensive as those in the UK or the EU..." (In fact, this is one of the primary sources of friction between the US and the EU over PNR (Passenger Name Data) in recent months/years.*) Clearly the privacy policy does not contain the relevant information required by Section 16 (1) (f). On the face of it therefore the TDA is in breach of the DPA.

In the circumstances, I can't help wondering how many other Government Departments, Agencies, &c have an equivalent 'error of omission' in their privacy policy statements, especially because of the burgeoning use of out-sourcing for processing of data.


* I've been meaning to do a post about this for some time - I promise I'll get round to it soon.